Skip to content
Education Training


La Trobe University 2 mins read
Lack of Consistency in Way Our Kids Are Taught








A survey of 284 Australian primary school teachers looking at the strategies used to teach reading comprehension reveals practices that are ad hoc, with little agreement within the Australian primary teaching community regarding the ways that reading skills are taught. 

The study, led by Reid Smith, a PhD student in La Trobe University’s Education Department, and was published in the journal, Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools,  

According to Mr Smith, the purpose was to examine teachers' beliefs about how children in the first 7 years of schooling develop reading comprehension skills and to characterize the self-reported practices and strategies they use to support children to comprehend connected text. “We found that Australian elementary school teachers hold a wide range of beliefs about reading instruction, some of which are in direct opposition to each other,” he said.  

The study found: 

  • little consensus as to how reading comprehension is taught at the primary school level  
  • no uniformity in how much time should be apportioned to different tasks relating to teaching reading comprehension 
  • commercial programs had significant penetration in schools, and many participants reported using multiple commercial programs, with varying levels of evidence
  • participants indicated that their most common source of knowledge about reading instruction was their own personal research, with few nominating university teacher education as a primary source of knowledge or expertise. 

According to lead co-author, Associate Professor Tanya Serry, despite recommendations about effective reading practices made by three national reviews undertaken in Australia, the US and the UK since 2000, reading instruction in Australian classrooms is still highly contested. “The “Reading Wars” debate impacts both the teaching of decoding and the teaching of comprehension,” she said. 

“Every day, Australian teachers are tasked with helping students develop reading comprehension. Given the importance of early reading instruction in preventing reading difficulties and promoting academic achievement the lack of consistency across teaching in Australia are of significant policy and practice interest.” 

According to Mr Reid Smith, although Australia has a national curriculum that provides a framework for schools in terms of what to teach, “there are few guidelines as to how much time is devoted to the teaching of reading comprehension or which instructional approaches or strategies should be used,” he said.  

“An additional issue is that the three national educational sectors (government-funded, Catholic and independent schools) are funded by differing combinations of federal government and student fees. These sectors vary in their policies, application of oversight, and governance, all of which can affect classroom practice in ways that are difficult to identify and measure.” 

Associate Professor Serry said that seven decades of evidence on the best way to teach reading comprehension “Isis to see the teaching as a progression from word-level identification and meanings to sentence- and text-level comprehension. Instruction should be focused on developing each of these aspects of comprehension through explicit instruction, with the teacher playing a primary role in the classroom,” she said. 

“Despite all this evidence its clear from our survey that significant differences remain in how teachers conceptualize their role in the classroom. 

In 2020, Professor Pamela Snow and Associate Professor Serry launched the Science of Language and Reading (SOLAR) Lab, at La Trobe University bringing together teachers and allied health professionals – including speech-language pathologists and psychologists – to ensure new knowledge is incorporated into classroom and intervention practice.


Contact details:

Tania Ewing



More from this category

  • Education Training
  • 12/07/2024
  • 11:20
La Trobe University

New pathway to teaching in Victoria

La Trobe University’s unique and highly successful employment-based postgraduate pathway program, Nexus, has been expanded into a new pilot employment-based undergraduate program announced by the Victorian Government (11 July). Nexus Undergraduate will see more than 300 dedicated Education Support staff and Koorie Education Support Officers gain teaching qualifications while undertaking paid employment in schools. La Trobe’s School of Education will receive around $2.5 million towards delivering the pilot program that will help address the national teacher shortage issue by enabling rural and regional education support staff to pursue a La Trobe Bachelor of Teaching, Secondary and Special Education degree program…

  • Education Training, Government Federal
  • 12/07/2024
  • 08:40
Independent Tertiary Education Council Australia (ITECA)

A Rise In Government Funded Students Masks A Flaw In The Skills Training System

A 5% rise in the number of government-funded students to 1,256,365 in 2023 masks the fact that government funding allocations limit student choice, with tens of thousands of students across the nation unable to study in their preferred course or with their preferred Registered Training Organisation (RTO). That’s the view of the Independent Tertiary Education Council Australia (ITECA), the peak body representing independent skills training, higher education, and international education providers. Data released this week by the National Centre for Vocational Education Research (NCVER) showed that in 2023, the total number of government-funded students rose by 59,830 to 1,256,365 students,…

  • Contains:
  • Education Training
  • 11/07/2024
  • 13:33
Independent Education Union - Queensland and Northern Territory (IEU-QNT)

Queensland education unions working to Close the Industrial Gap

As NAIDOC Week 2024 celebrations are underway across Australia, the unions representing teachers and school leaders in both state and non-government Queensland schools are pleased to release landmark industrial guidelines to establish equitable benchmarks for the employment of First Nations education workers. The Queensland Teachers’ Union (QTU) and the Independent Education Union - Queensland and Northern Territory branch (IEU-QNT) said the guidelines were the culmination of years of work by First Nations union members and other stakeholders committed to closing the industrial gap experienced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander language and culture educators in schools. First Languages Australia (FLA),…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.