Skip to content
Environment, Political

Shoppers being misled by eco-certifications on Macquarie Harbour farmed salmon

The Australia Institute 2 mins read

MORE THAN 80 GROUPS WORLDWIDE DEMAND FARMED SALMON ACCREDITATIONS STOP GREENWASHING THE EXTINCTION OF THE MAUGEAN SKATE

For immediate release on July 25, 2023

More than 80 organisations from around the globe are calling for the accreditation schemes, Best Aquaculture Practices and GlobalG.A.P., to immediately revoke their ‘sustainability’ certifications from farmed salmon and trout raised in waters adjacent to the World Heritage Area, Macquarie Harbour, Tasmania.

The demand comes as federal and state government workshops are held in Hobart this week to decide on urgent action to prevent the extinction of the Maugean skate – a rare animal related to sharks and dating back to the time of dinosaurs.

Despite scientific evidence that industrial fish farms in Macquarie Harbour are having a major impact on the waterway’s health and skate numbers, all three salmon farming companies operating in the harbour are certified as “environmentally responsible” by BAP or GlobalG.A.P.

Signatories from 17 countries have sent open letters to both schemes demanding withdrawal of certification, condemning the misleading of unsuspecting shoppers, and calling for an end to greenwashing the extinction of the prehistoric skate. 

The signatories include marine, shark conservation, animal welfare, and community groups, as well as independent scientists, a public policy think tank, and award-winning authors.

Found only in Macquarie Harbour, the endangered Maugean Skate is one of the listed natural values of the World Heritage Area.

Scientists from the University of Tasmania’s Institute of Marine and Antarctic Studies renewed their alarm recently after reporting a dramatic collapse in Maugean skate numbers with almost half disappearing in less than seven years.

The scientists attribute the Maugean skate’s decline to the degraded environmental conditions in the Harbour, particularly dissolved oxygen levels, and explicitly named fish farms as one of the main causes of low dissolved oxygen levels in Macquarie Harbour.

Quotes:

“Major supermarkets rely on these certifications to sell farmed salmon and ocean trout with their “responsibly sourced” logos as part of their sustainable seafood policies. But there is nothing responsible about driving one of the rarest skate species in the world to extinction.” - Kelly Roebuck, SeaChoice 

“This is certified ecocide. The Maugean Skate has one critical habitat, one chance at survival, the science is there, and the urgent action that is required to save this animal is simply not happening. Instead, we have greenwashing.” - Jessica Coughlan, Neighbours of Fish Farms 

“These certifications must not shirk their responsibility here.  They cannot palm this off to the auditors or wait until the companies’ next audit to address this dire situation. Macquarie Harbour fish farm certifications should be immediately revoked, or they will be the first certification schemes in the world to certify an extinction of a species.'' - Alistair Allan, Bob Brown Foundation

“Shoppers should be outraged to know that not only are they being misled by these certification claims, but they are unknowingly contributing to the demise of a species as old as the dinosaurs,” - Rebecca Howarth, Environment Tasmania

“The federal government is in Hobart again this week because the Tasmanian government cannot be trusted to prevent the extinction of this species. Meanwhile, so-called ‘sustainability’ certification continues to greenwash the unsustainable practices of the salmon industry.” - Eloise Carr, Tasmanian Director, the Australia Institute

Media contacts:

Kelly Roebuck, SeaChoice [email protected] 0432.660.064

Jessica Coughlan, Neighbours of Fish Farms [email protected] 0431.684.741

Alistair Allan, Bob Brown Foundation  [email protected] 0432.352.329

Eloise Carr, the Australia Institute [email protected].au 0414.704.709

Backgrounder:

Letter to Best Aquaculture Practices 

Tassal (Cooke Aquaculture) and Petuna (Sealord) are BAP certified

Letter to GlobalG.A.P. 

Huon Aquaculture (JBS) is GlobalG.A.P. certified

IMAS Interim ReportMacquarie Harbour Maugean skate population status and monitoring 

Media

More from this category

  • Environment, Transport Automotive
  • 12/12/2025
  • 14:27
NALSPA

Electric Car Discount review must drive clean energy transition and cost-of-living relief

The National Automotive Leasing and Salary Packaging Association (NALSPA) has today welcomed the federal government’s announcement of the statutory review of the Electric Car Discount, noting that the policy continues to be highly effective in encouraging Australians to make the switch to cleaner cars.The federal government announced today that next year it will review the Electric Car Discount, otherwise known as the EV FBT exemption which came into effect in July 2022.The review will consider the operation of the Electric Car Discount over the first three years it has been in place, as required by the legislation.“We will actively participate…

  • Manufacturing, Political
  • 12/12/2025
  • 12:19
Australian Workers' Union

AWU welcomes government action to secure Tomago’s future

The Australian Workers' Union has strongly endorsed today's announcement that theTomago aluminium smelter will remain operational, with federal and state governments committing to work with Rio Tinto on a long-term solution. “This is a pivotal moment for Australian manufacturing,” AWU National Secretary Paul Farrow said. "The AWU has been knocking on every door - federal, state, company, thought leaders - to make sure the right people were talking to each other and working toward a solution. We're pleased that effort has paid off. "For months we've been saying that Tomago isn't just another industrial site. It's the test case for…

  • Oil Mining Resources, Political
  • 12/12/2025
  • 12:06
Mining and Energy Union

MEU: Coal communities need stability and consistency following Net Zero Commission report

The Mining and Energy Union has responded to the NSW Net Zero Commission’s Coal Mining Emissions Spotlight Report, emphasising the continuing importance of coal mining to the state's economy and regional communities, and the need for clear, consistent emissions policy. MEU General Secretary Grahame Kelly said coal mining remains a foundation of regional prosperity in NSW, supporting jobs, local small businesses and billions in annual state revenue. “Coal mining delivers more than $3 billion a year in royalties for NSW and supports thousands of secure, well-paid regional jobs,” Mr Kelly said. “It also accounts forjust12 per cent of the state’s…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.