Skip to content
Employment Relations

How employers should respond when employees’ problematic behaviour resurfaces online

BrightHR 2 mins read

 

13 September 2023, Australia - Hollywood actors Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis have found themselves in hot water after it came to light that they sent letters of support for a former colleague who was convicted of rape. Ashton Kutcher has faced renewed criticism this week after a 20-year-old video resurfaced in which he made inappropriate comments about actress Hilary Duff, who was 15 years old at the time.

 

In the age of social media, employers may face difficult decisions when historical inappropriate material surfaces online about one of their employees. 

 

Thea Watson, Chief International Growth Officer at BrightHR, says there are a few options available to employers in this situation, “In today's digital age, everything you do online can be traced back to you. This means that anything you post or share, even if they are from years ago, could potentially come back to haunt you. While a video of you dancing the Macarena after a few drinks might not be a big deal, something that could be considered illegal could have serious consequences for your career.

 

“Employers have the right to protect their reputation from any negative impact caused by their employees' actions. This can include social media posts, even those made in the past. However, as with all employment relations issues, employers must always handle incidents fairly and reasonably, or they risk being sued for unfair dismissal.

 

“Such incidents should be managed on a case-by-case basis especially if there is no link to the workplace, there might be limited scope for taking action against the employee. However, if there is a direct link to the company, disciplinary action from employers may be appropriate. It’s best to set a policy on the use of social media and communicate this clearly with employees, so they know the standards expected of them.

 

If an employee's social media post violates company policy, employers have the right to exercise due diligence, investigate, and commence disciplinary action where appropriate. Even if there isn’t a written policy in place, employees may still be held accountable for their actions if they post something that is detrimental to the company's reputation. This is especially true if the post reflects badly on the company or suggests that it condones inappropriate behaviour, and the outcome of any disciplinary action will depend on the specific circumstances of the case.

 

The more shares a video gets, the more damage it can cause to an organisation's reputation. However, it is difficult for employers to set a specific number of shares that would trigger disciplinary action, as this could lead to inconsistent treatment of employees. It is best to handle each situation consistently, regardless of the number of shares the video has received. Ultimately, it is important to consider all the facts of the case and examine the situation before deciding the best course of action.”

 

- ENDS - 

 

 

Editor Notes:

  • BrightHR provides award-winning HR and H&S software and advisory solutions for SMEs, servicing over 22,000 clients in Australia and New Zealand on workplace relations and workplace health & safety issues. It was founded in 2015 to help Australian and New Zealand SMEs navigate their obligations under the relevant legislation. It does this via a suite of innovative applications and advice line, where businesses can access people management tools, receive guidance, education and speak with their team of workplace relations specialists.
  • Where possible in online media publications, please link back to BrightHR’s homepage.

 


Contact details:

Molly Chandran – Public Relations Specialist, Employsure  

T: 0438 560 779 | E: [email protected]  

More from this category

  • Business Company News, Employment Relations
  • 11/12/2025
  • 13:37
December 11, 2025

Update: Federal Court finalises Bupa and ACCC settlement

Bupa Health Insurance Australia acknowledges the orders the Federal Court made today in response to breaches of Australian Consumer Law. The proceedings related to the incorrect assessment of certain mixed coverage and uncategorised item claims and related eligibility checks between May 2018 and August 2023. Following the jointly proposed submissions from the ACCC and Bupa Australia, the Federal Court has approved the orders including an agreed penalty of $35 million. Weremaindeeply sorry for these errors and have apologised to our affected customers for the impact this has had on them and their families and have taken actions to ensure this…

  • Employment Relations, Government SA
  • 09/12/2025
  • 19:31
PSA

SA Justice System in crisis as Corrections Officers vote to enter unprecedented 72 hour lockdown

WHAT: SA’s Corrections Officers vote whether to continue a statewide prisonlockdown for 72 hours WHEN: 8am Wednesday the 10th of December 2025 WHERE: Yatala Prison, Grand Junction Road, Northfield MORE INFO: SA Justice System in crisis as Corrections Officers vote to enter 72 hour lockdown Corrections Officers across seven of South Australia's prisons will vote tomorrow morning at 8am on whether to continue a 48 hour strike which has plunged them into an unprecedented lockdown. They will be joined by Home Detention Officers who will also decide whether to down tools. They are responsible for the ankle monitoring of 1500…

  • Employment Relations, Government SA
  • 08/12/2025
  • 20:16
PSA

SA Prisons to enter 48 hours of lockdown as Corrections Officers vote whether to continue strike

WHAT:SA’s Corrections Officers vote on whether to continuelockdown for 48 hours WHEN: 7.30am Tuesday the 9th of December 2025 WHERE: Yatala Prison, Grand Junction Road,Northfield MORE INFO: Corrections Officers across seven of South Australia's prisons will vote tomorrow morning at 7.30am on whether to continue a 24 hour strike which has plunged the prisons intolockdown. Corrections Officers voted this morning to strike for 24 hours at stop work meetings atYatala Labour Prison, Port Augusta Prison, Mobilong Prison, Port Lincoln Prison, Cadell Prison, and Adelaide Women’s Prison. 2000+ of the state’s prisoners have been confined to their cells ever since. The…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.