Skip to content
Disability, Government Federal

People with an acquired brain injury (ABI) let down by Australia’s judicial system

RMIT University 3 mins read

A criminal justice system expert and disability advocate talk about key issues relating to people with disabilities in the criminal justice system, which they hope will be addressed in the Final Report of the Disability Royal Commission which will be released publicly today. 

RMIT’s Centre for Innovative Justice provided two submissions to the Royal Commission into Violence, Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disability which included 36 recommendations. 

Stan Winford, Associate Director of Research, Innovation and Reform, Centre for Innovative Justice 

Topics: Disability Royal Commission, NDIS, acquired brain injury and the justice system 

“The criminal justice system has failed to recognise acquired brain injuries (ABI) as a disability and has failed, time and again, to provide people with an ABI with respect and support.  

“Two per cent of Australians have an ABI, but in Victorian prisons, that number is far higher. One study by Corrections Victoria found that 42 per cent of male prisoners and 33 per cent of female prisoners have an ABI.  

“A lack of education and awareness, funding, services for diagnosis and assessment, all inhibit people with an ABI who have been in contact with the system to rehabilitate.  

“Fragmented and inconsistent responses to people with disabilities in the criminal justice and disability service systems means that their needs are rarely responded to appropriately.   

“Quite often, people with an ABI are stuck in a vicious cycle where they are in constant contact with the justice system due to the lack of appropriate support. 

“One of the recurring issues identified in our work has been difficulty meeting NDIS eligibility criteria.  

“There is a distinct lack of access to services for diagnosis and assessment available for individuals in custody, as well as a lack of documentation to prove diagnosis for those already assessed. 

“Many disability services do not provide services in custodial settings because of internal policies or barriers, or a belief it is not possible to do so. 

“Big changes need to be made and the government needs to be working with disability self-advocates and developing innovative approaches to embedding lived experience in service design.  

“Our submission highlighted some of the issues, barriers and challenges for people in custody accessing and maintaining a NDIS package, and set out recommendations connected to four priority areas to address these issues: 

  • Housing: improving pathways into secure long-term housing for people with disabilities in the criminal justice system 
  • Early intervention: improving early intervention and diversion for people with disabilities in contact with or at risk of contact with the criminal justice system 
  • Disability and trauma awareness: improving trauma and disability-informed practice in the criminal justice system 
  • System collaboration and information sharing: improving cross-sector communication and information sharing to improve outcomes of people with disabilities in the criminal justice system.” 

Stan Winford is a legal and justice system expert with experience in innovation and reform, including human centred design, disability in the justice and corrections systems and criminal law. 

Dorothy Armstrong, Adviser and Peer Support Worker for the Centre for Innovative Justice’s Supporting Justice project 

Topics: acquired brain injury, lived experience, criminal justice system 

“There needs to be a greater investment in supporting the use of lived experience to inform criminal justice system policy, particularly for people with disability in the criminal justice system.    

“Everyone in the criminal justice system experiences a level of trauma because we are a part of a system that is failing people and the community.  

“Currently, the way people are treated in the criminal justice system, particularly those people with poorly understood disabilities and mental ill-health, creates further harm.  

The immediate result is push-back a reaction that can create an unsafe environment for everyone.   

Our system should be working better; it should be about justice and restorative outcomes  

“There is so much that needs to change. A lot of the problems for people with ABI in the justice system have not improved since my experience with it. The support is not there. The funding is not there. The understanding is not there. 

“People with lived experience can offer insights into how a system operates in ways that a person with learned experience cannot. Including lived experience in policy design and implementation is vital. 

“If people with a disability in the justice system don’t experience respect and support, it’s highly likely that they’ll continue the offending cycle they're on.”   

Dorothy Armstrong is an Adviser and Peer Support Worker in the Centre for Innovative Justice’s Supporting Justice project. Dorothy gave evidence to the Royal Commission regarding the impact of the criminal justice system on people with disability. As a person with lived experience of the criminal justice system, Dorothy is one of the founding members of the Voices for Change self-advocacy group for people with acquired brain injury.   


Contact details:

Stan Winford, 0438 080 608 or kristann.winford@rmit.edu.au     

Dorothy Armstrong, contact Stan Winford or RMIT External Affairs and Media 

General media enquiries: RMIT External Affairs and Media, 0439 704 077 or news@rmit.edu.au 

More from this category

  • Government Federal, National News Current Affairs
  • 16/06/2024
  • 08:22
JEREMY LEIBLER, PRESIDENT, ZIONIST FEDERATION OF AUSTRALIA

STATEMENT ON INVESTIGATION BY THE NINE NEWSPAPERS: HIZB UT-TAHRIR MUST BE URGENTLY BANNED

According to this investigation,Hizb ut-Tahrir – banned in Germany, and proscribed as a terrorist organisation in the United Kingdom – has led national boycotts of Jewish-owned businesses and incited violent protests in Caulfield that required a synagogue to be evacuated; they have infiltrated Australia’s leading university, are glorifying terrorism and distributing extremist material, and are covertly using front organisations to mainstream their extremism with a combined 33,000 followers. We should not have any doubt as to what Hizb ut-Tahrir’s key players and supporters mean when they refer to 7 October as a “day of courage,” or when they share videos…

  • Government Federal, Medical Health Aged Care
  • 16/06/2024
  • 08:00
ASU

Unions move to stop wage theft of disability workers

Unions will on Monday move to stop dodgy NDIS providers stealing $16,000 a year from dedicated disability support workers by paying them below the minimum wage. The ASU, with support from the AWU, UWU and HSU, is applying to the Fair Work Commission to ensure providers pay staff at least the minimum wage for social and community services employees, as they are funded to do. About 10 per cent of providers have been deliberately misclassifying up to 30,000 NDIS workers as home care workers, which has a lower award rate, and pocketing the difference. The difference in the hourly rates…

  • Disability, Medical Health Aged Care
  • 14/06/2024
  • 09:44
Audika

NEGLECTED SENSE: 73% ADMIT HEARING FALLS BEHIND SIGHT IN ATTENTION

A new survey commissioned by hearing care expertsAudika Hearing Clinic reveals surveyed Australians prioritise their sight over hearing, despite over three quarters (77%) knowing someone who is hard of hearing. Most (86%) respondents ranked sight as their most important sense, with hearing coming in second (69%)[1]. Unsurprisingly, this is reflected in which sense they care for more, with almost three quarters (73%) of respondents admitting that between hearing and sight, their hearing was the most neglected[1]. Reasons for neglect: Lack of understanding and stigma Both stigma and a lack of understanding can impact the way Australians prioritise their senses. Interestingly,…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.