Skip to content
Employment Relations


The Brotherhood of St. Laurence 3 mins read

Growing Pains, a new research report from the Brotherhood of St. Laurence (BSL) and the University of Melbourne, has found that the current Family Tax Benefit (FTB) system is not meeting the needs of low-income families, while creating lifelong barriers to women’s economic security in Australia.

Family Tax Benefit (FTB) parts A and B are payments the Federal Government introduced in 2000 to assist eligible families with the costs of caring for children. Paid to the carer of children – predominately women – they play an important role in reducing child poverty in Australia.

Possibly the most complex part of the social security system to understand – even by experts – Family Tax Benefit payments have been tweaked over the past 20 years to a point that they are no longer meeting the needs of the families that rely on them.

For low-income families these payments are a critical lifeline. They contribute over a third of total disposable income for some, keeping parents and children above the poverty line.

When examining the adequacy and complexity of the payments, the Growing Pains report found that:

  • Inadequate payments leave families at risk of poverty. Pauses in the indexation of FTB A and FTB B payments over the past decade have reduced the value of the payment. The benchmarking of FTB A family payments to pension rates, adopted in the 1980s, has also been removed, putting families at risk of financial hardship.
  • Reduced coverage leaves some families missing out. Frequent pauses in the indexation, coupled with adjustments in income thresholds, resulted in payment coverage declining to 46 percent of children aged 0 to 18 benefited from FTB A in 2020-21, a notable decrease from 66 percent in 2000-01.
  • FTB payments entrench gender roles and create a barrier to equity. Women, who comprise the majority of secondary earners in Australian households, are most disadvantaged by the FTB system, with lifelong implications for women’s economic security and gender equity.
  • Complex administration and compliance arrangements create risks. Complex rules have led to high levels of underpayments and debts, causing additional stress for families, with one in five recipients incurring a debt in 2020-21.
  • High Effective Marginal Tax Rates (EMTRs) create a disincentive for paid work. The system's income thresholds mean caregivers (mostly women) moving from unpaid work in the home to paid work can face effective marginal tax rates of up to 80 per cent, making it harder for families to make ends meet.


BSL is calling on the Federal Government to take immediate action to improve adequacy and reduce the administrative risks of the current FTB system by reinstating the indexation of FTB in line with pensions, reviewing shared care arrangements and removing the Maintenance Income Test.

The report identifies that broader reform to family assistance payments is also necessary, with further research on the level of family payments required to lift children out of poverty a critical first step. BSL identifies four options for consideration:

  • A single per-child payment that would replace the two-tier system of FTB A and FTB B.
  • A universal per-child payment, which would eliminate the high EMTRs that are generated by the current FTB A and FTB B payments, supporting both work participation and gender equity goals.
  • Child payment eligibility to be based on the individual income of the carer who receives the payment, instead of the joint income of partners.
  • Child payments income to be tested like Parental Leave Pay, ensuring that those with low incomes obtain the maximum benefit.


“The system as it stands entrenches outdated gender roles around care and work, discouraging increased workforce participation by secondary earners – particularly those with weaker earning capacity – the majority of whom are women,” says Growing Pains co-author Dr Emily Porter.

“In the current landscape where many employers are actively seeking more workers, implementing simple changes could significantly increase the participation of women in the workforce. This wouldn't just result in a fairer outcome for women seeking employment, but also prove beneficial for the overall economy.”

“We need the Government to urgently recognise and value unpaid care work, while removing work disincentives to adequately support families and children and build women’s economic security over the long term,” Porter said.

Read the full report here.

For media enquiries contact Steph Jones, BSL Communications and Media Manager: 0482 163 395 or

More from this category

  • Employment Relations, Mental Health
  • 12/02/2024
  • 14:05
atWork Australia

atWork Australia supports young people facing mental health challenges to secure meaningful employment

Navigating the employment landscape can be challenging for many people, particularly young people. atWork Australia is now shedding light on the pressing issue of youth unemployment, specifically among those who are experiencing challenges with their mental health and wellbeing, which can add another layer of difficulty to their job search. A recent report from the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare highlighted that 16% of young people aged 15–24 are unemployed, an increase from 12% of the previous year1. Furthermore, headspace National Youth Mental Health Foundation found that almost one third of young people are disengaged with work/study2. For young…

  • Contains:
  • Employment Relations, Industrial Relations
  • 09/02/2024
  • 17:01
Wage Inspectorate Victoria

Red Rooster Wodonga fined $5500 for child employment breaches, ordered to pay costs

Red Rooster Wodonga has been fined $5500 and ordered to pay $4000 in costs in the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court after pleading guilty to 29 breaches of Victoria’s child employment laws. Wage Inspectorate Victoria, the state’s child employment regulator, began investigating Wodonga Food Pty Ltd, trading as Red Rooster Wodonga, in August 2022 after receiving a tip-off from the community alleging the business was employing children under 15 years of age without the relevant permits. Today, Red Rooster Wodonga pleaded guilty to: employing 10 children under the age of 15 without a permit on 154 occasions failing to ensure the children…

  • Employment Relations, Utilities
  • 08/02/2024
  • 05:30

NSW energy workers to strike for fair pay

More than 1,000 workers across energy generator TransGrid and distributor Endeavour Energy will on today walk off the job for 24 hours in separate industrial action, to demand a fair pay rise.Electrical Trades Union members will rally at Parramatta Square for a wage deal that keeps pace with living costs that have skyrocketed since the pandemic. At Endeavour Energy,wages have risen just 10.5 per cent since 2019 while inflation is up 18 per cent. At Transgrid wages have only increased eight per cent over the same period.The same tightfistedness has not applied to Endeavour Energy corporate overhead costs which are…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.