Skip to content
COVID19, Legal

Constitutional complaint brought against Federal Court Judge for concealing pharma connections

PJ O'Brien & Associates 3 mins read


SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA, 22 March 2024: A complaint filed with the Federal Court Chief Justice Debra Mortimer today alleges that Federal Court judge, her Honour Justice Helen Rofe, concealed her connections to Pfizer and the pharmaceutical industry before dismissing a case, to Pfizer’s advantage.

The complaint was filed by law firm PJ O’Brien & Associates.

Katie Ashby-Koppens is instructing solicitor on the case VID510/2023, which Justice Rofe dismissed on the matter of standing in a decision handed down on 1 March 2024.

The applicant, Dr Julian Fidge, sought an injunction to prevent Pfizer and Moderna from distributing their mRNA Covid vaccines. Dr Fidge alleges the vaccines contain unlicenced genetically modified organisms (GMOs), which is a criminal offence in Australia under the Gene Technology Act 2000.

If the action were successful, it would carry serious financial and reputational damage to both Pfizer and Moderna. As respondents, Pfizer and Moderna stood to benefit from Justice Rofe’s dismissal of the case.

The complaint against Justice Rofe alleges serious misconduct possibly rising to misbehaviour by the failure to disqualify herself or disclose her significant prior relationship with Pfizer.

Justice Rofe was appointed to the Federal Court on 12 July 2021 after being called to the Bar in 2001. When at the Bar, Justice Rofe directly and indirectly represented Pfizer on at least five occasions between the years 2003-2006 (see page 8 of linked complaint for the detailed list).

Additionally, Justice Rofe has substantial affiliations and associations with the pharmaceutical and scientific research industry.

Her Honour’s extended family established the Grimwade family pharmaceutical fortune and later ran leading Australian biomedical research organisation the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute (WEHI).

The WEHI has received funding of hundreds of millions in taxpayer dollars and over US$30 million from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

Professionally, Justice Rofe sat on the Bolton Clarke Human Research and Ethics Committee for 10 years. Bolton Clark received significant provisions of grant money from her Honour’s cousin, Sir Andrew, in his role as Chairman of the Felton Bequests Committee. Sir Andrew served a period as the honorary President of the WEHI for 14 years, serving on the Board from 1963 to 1992.

In view of these allegations, PJ O’Brien & Associates is calling on the Upper and Lower Houses of Parliament to investigate Justice Rofe’s conduct, as is their prerogative under Section 72(2) of the Constitution.

The last time a Parliamentary investigation into potential misbehaviour of a judge was established under Section 72(2) of the Constitution was in the case of Justice Lionel Murphy, in May 1986. The investigation was discontinued when Justice Murphy announced that he had received a terminal cancer diagnosis. Justice Murphy passed away in October 1986.

Quotes attributed to Katie Ashby-Koppens, instructing solicitor, PJ O’Brien & Associates

“Judges are duty bound to disclose not only potential conflicts, but also perceived conflicts. Failing to disclose this information is not just a breach of common courtesy, but is a breach of the judicial obligations of a sitting judge.”

“There are 17 judges who sit on the Federal Court Melbourne Registry. Justice Rofe was not the only judge available to hear the matter.”

“Justice Rofe’s dismissal of our case should be voided and our matter should be heard by a judge with no presenting conflicts, as should all matters in the Australian judicial system.”

“We have asked Chief Justice Mortimer to investigate our complaint. Additionally, we call on the Parliament of Australia to investigate allegations of misbehaviour of a sitting judge. If the allegations of misbehaviour are proven, the Parliament may remove Justice Rofe from the bench.”


Katie Ashby-Koppens
Lawyer, PJ O’Brien & Associates Phone: +61 435 791 200

Read the complaint against Justice Rofe: HERE

Summary of the GMO case VID510/2023: court-covid19-drugs-gmo-pfizer-moderna-law

Key Facts:

- A Federal Court judge concealed pharma connections before dismissing case in Pfizer's favour
- A complaint has been brought against Justice Helen Rofe requesting investigation into misconduct

About us:

PJ O’Brien & Associates, NSW law firm

Contact details:

Katie Ashby-Koppens
Lawyer, PJ O’Brien & Associates Phone: +61 435 791 200


More from this category

  • Legal
  • 16/04/2024
  • 13:22
Wage Inspectorate Victoria

TK Maxx pleads guilty to child employment breaches after ignoring regulator’s warning

TK Maxx has pleaded guilty in the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court to 7 breaches of Victoria’s child employment laws at its Werribee store. Wage Inspectorate Victoria, the state’s child employment regulator, began investigating TJX Australia Pty Limited, trading as TK Maxx, as part of a compliance blitz in December 2022. On 8 December 2022, the Wage Inspectorate found TK Maxx Werribee was employing a child under 15 without a permit, so it warned the business that the child must cease work immediately. However, TK Maxx Werribee proceeded to employ another child without a permit the very next week. The investigation also…

  • Crime, Legal
  • 15/04/2024
  • 15:34
Parliament of Australia

Committee to review proposed crime-related laws

TheParliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security(the Committee) has commenced a review of theCrimes and Other Legislation Amendment (Omnibus No. 1) Bill 2024. The Bill amends and clarifies the intended operation of provisions in various crime-related statutes, including by: expressly authorising police, when executing search warrants issued under theCrimes Act 1914orProceeds of Crime Act 2002, to seize digital assets, such as cryptocurrency, including by accessing a person’s digital wallet and transferring its contents amending theProceeds of Crime Act 2002to extend the investigative and freezing powers that currently apply to financial institutions to also apply in relation to digital currency exchanges…

  • Crime, Legal
  • 15/04/2024
  • 15:33
Parliament of Australia

PJCIS to review new declared areas bill

At the request of the Attorney-General, theParliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security(PJCIS) has commenced a review of theCounter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment (Declared Areas) Bill 2024. The amendments in the Bill would ensure the continuation of the declared areas offence in section 119.2 of theCriminal Code Act 1995. The offence, which is due to sunset on 7 September 2024, is an element of the Australian Government’s efforts to stop Australians becoming foreign fighters. The Bill would extend the offence for another three years, to 7 September 2027, and would also provide that section 119.3—the provision under which the Minister for Foreign…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.