Skip to content
Community, Political

Compulsory income management doing more harm than good: Study

Charles Darwin University 2 mins read
The study explored the effectiveness of compulsory income management from the perspective of welfare professionals.

Compulsory income management (CIM) in the Northern Territory is perceived to be ineffective in reducing harm, can contribute to situations of family violence and is incompatible with the needs of welfare recipients, a new study led by Charles Darwin University (CDU) has found. 

The study, conducted by members of CDU’s Faculty of Health alongside Monash University, interviewed 26 participants who are experts in social welfare programs or policies, highly experienced in providing support to welfare recipients, or have an in-depth understanding of CIM in the lives of welfare recipients.

CIM was established in the Northern Territory in 2007 and restricts a portion of a participants income support payment which cannot be used to gamble, purchase alcohol and other prohibited products. The BasicsCard is still active in the NT, alongside the Enhanced Income Management program launched in March 2023. 

The participants were asked a series of questions about their thoughts on the long-term role and impact of CIM in the Northern Territory.

The findings explored the impact of CIM on social harms, regional and remote areas, the administrative burden it places on individuals and organisations, CIM as the dominant source of welfare provision, and CIM as a method of social control.

Lead author and CDU Senior Lecturer in Professional Practice – Families and Communities Dr Steven Roche said the study concluded CIM was considered a punitive approach to reducing harm and was incompatible with the needs of welfare recipients. 

“The findings detail CIM’s negligible impact on behaviour change around social harms and suggest that CIM can exacerbate issues such as family violence, where CIM is weaponised by men who use violence in situations of family violence,” Dr Roche said. 

According to Dr Roche, study participants detailed how welfare recipients found ways to bypass CIM to purchase prohibited items, how CIM doesn’t prevent or reduce family violence, and how it doesn’t address the underlying issues of harm from alcohol and other drugs. 

“A key theme also identified among participants was the challenges that CIM could create for welfare recipients residing in regional and remote areas,” Dr Roche said. 

“CIM was viewed by participants as exacerbating the existing cost of living pressures, particularly in remote areas where consumer choice is limited, and travel is expensive.”

Dr Roche said participants considered CIM a “top-down approach” with little effort made to work with communities to identify ways to address social harms among welfare recipients. 

“A policy reform agenda involving genuine community consultation is desperately needed to better understand the complexities of CIM in the NT that holds principles of community-based policy development at its heart,” Dr Roche said. 

Perspectives on the ongoing impact of compulsory income management in the Northern Territory was published in The Australian Journal of Social Issues. 


Contact details:

Raphaella Saroukos she/her
Research Communications Officer
Marketing, Media & Communications
Larrakia Country
T: +61 8 8946 6721
E: rmedia@cdu.edu.au
W: cdu.edu.au

Media

More from this category

  • Community
  • 30/05/2024
  • 16:22
James Milson Village

JAMES MILSON VILLAGE CELEBRATES 50 YEARS OF COMMUNITY EXCELLENCE WITH PATRON MICHAEL O’DEA

James Milson Village (JMV) will celebrate its 50th anniversary on Sunday, June 2. This milestone marks five decades of exceptional care and community building.…

  • Contains:
  • Education Training, Political
  • 30/05/2024
  • 11:35
Christian Schools Australia, Associated Christian Schools and Australian Association of Christian

Listen to Justice Rothman – Schools Need a Positive Right

30 May 2024 – For Immediate Release Listen to Justice Rothman – Schools Need a Positive Right Christian schools are calling on the Albanese Government to ensure certainty and clarity for faith-based schools by establishing a positive right to religious freedom as recommended by Justice Stephen Rothman. In a speech to a Christian schools conference earlier today, Dr Mark Fowler quoted extensively from a recent speech by Justice Stephen Rothman, where he outlined his preferred approach to resolving issues of conflict between various human rights. As Dr Fowler indicated (emphasis added): “Justice Rothman’s views are unequivocal. The conflict between successive…

  • Contains:
  • National News Current Affairs, Political
  • 30/05/2024
  • 08:05
Susan McKinnon Foundation

Susan McKinnon Foundation appoints Mike Baird as inaugural CEO

The Susan McKinnon Foundation (SMF) has today announced a significant new chapter with the appointment of former NSW Premier Mike Baird AO as its inaugural Chief Executive Officer, and Holly Kramer as Chair. SMF founders Grant Rule and Sophie Oh said Mr Baird, in this new role will significantly scale the Foundation’s activity in the areas of improving Australia’s public administration, supporting effective political leadership and strengthening the nation’s democratic institutions. “We are thrilled to announce Mike as our inaugural CEO. His reputation as a centrist, can-do leader who has been highly successful in politics and business, makes him the…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.