Skip to content
Finance Investment, Political

Super for a house could cost taxpayers $1 trillion

Super Members Council 3 mins read
  • Media:

New modelling shows a push for young Australians to raid all their super for a house deposit could cost taxpayers a cumulative $1 trillion1.

And a policy to encourage super withdrawals capped at $50,000 could still create a $300 billion cost to federal coffers across coming decades.

The modelling – commissioned by the Super Members Council - shows pension costs climb exponentially as first home buyers start to retire with far less super in the coming decades and are forced to rely more heavily on the taxpayer-funded age pension.

To meet the rising Budget costs, future Governments may have to increase taxes or cut services to offset the extra fiscal pressure created by the bigger age pension outlays.

At its peak, the capped super for a house policy could cost taxpayers an extra $8 billion per year, while the latest push to uncap it would cost taxpayers an extra $25 billion a year.

Previous Super Members Council modelling also shows the policy would simply raise capital city house prices by $75,000 – forcing future generations of young Australians to wait even longer to buy.

Super Members Council CEO Misha Schubert said a growing body of expert evidence showed the policy would not lift home ownership rates – it would only make housing affordability worse while eroding retirement savings and leaving all Australians a tax bill.  

“It’s economically reckless. It sets a policy trap for young Australians because it hikes house prices and blows a Budget blackhole in the decades ahead mostly by pushing up age pension costs – which every taxpayer would pay,” she said.  

“Ideas to break the seal on super just leave people with less savings in retirement and a bigger bill for all taxpayers.”

“We all desperately want more Australians to own their own home, but this idea won’t achieve that. It’s unfair to lump the next generations of Australians with a policy that would only make the housing affordability crisis worse by driving up house prices.”

“We urge a sensible rethink on any policy ideas that undermine the strength and success of super to continue to deliver for all Australians in retirement.” 

All credible economists confirm that a push to raid super for house deposits – whether capped or uncapped would just drive-up house prices - overheating the inflated housing market and pushing the dream of home ownership further away. 

The modelling – completed by Deloitte - is based on a rigorous microsimulation model accounting for population change, super contributions and balances, tax and pension expenditures.

It finds a capped super for a house deposit policy risks:

  • costing the Budget more than $300 billion by the end of the century and $40 billion cumulatively by 2060 - mostly due to the rising age pension bill but also a loss of tax revenue on super earnings
  • adding an extra $320 million a year in costs to the Budget by 2030, more than $3 billion per year at 2060, and peaking at an extra $8 billion a year.

The latest uncapped super for a house deposit policy push risks:

  • costing taxpayers around $1 trillion by the end of the century and a cumulative extra $200 billion by 2060
  • adding an extra $2.5 billion a year to the Budget by 2030, $15 billion per year by the mid-2060s, and peaking at $25 billion a year towards the end of the century.  

SMC analysis predicts the current capped policy proposal would unleash a massive price hike that would push up prices by 9% or $75,000 for median house in Australia’s major capital cities. An uncapped scheme would set off an even bigger property price hike and cost future taxpayers billions in higher pension costs.

The creation of super is a remarkable Australian achievement that delivers a dignified retirement for millions – and it is rightly the envy of the world. Any time politicians float using super for something else, it undermines its purpose to deliver strong returns for all Australians.

SMC analysis shows a 30-year-old couple who withdrew $35,000 each from their super could retire with about $195,000 less in today’s dollars.

Table 1: Property price hike from proposal that allows first home buyers to use up to $50,000 from super

Capital city

Median house price*

Supercharged price hike

Median after price hike

Difference

Sydney

$1,128,300

7%

$1,206,500

$78,200

Melbourne

$780,500

9%

$849,300

$68,900

Brisbane

$787,200

10%

$865,100

$77,900

Adelaide

$711,600

4%

$740,400

$28,800

Perth

$660,800

13%

$746,800

$86,100

Weighted five city average

$859,700

9%

$934,100

$74,400

Notes: *CoreLogic Hedonic Home Value Index as at 31 December 2023. Prices rounded to the nearest hundred. Property prices encompass both houses and units. First home buyers typically enter the housing market at more affordable price points. However, increased demand from first home buyers will flow through to median property prices as represented in the table.

Source: SMC analysis.

 


About us:

About the Super Members Council: We are a strong voice advocating for more than 11 million Australians who have over $1.5 trillion in retirement savings managed by profit-to-member superannuation funds. Our purpose is to protect and advance their interests throughout their lives, advocating on their behalf to ensure superannuation policy is stable, effective, and equitable. We produce rigorous research and analysis and work with Parliamentarians and policy makers across the full breadth of Parliament.

 


Contact details:

James Dowling: 0429 437 851, jdowling@smcaustralia.com

Media

Attachments

Super-for-a-house-could-cost-taxpayers-1-trillion.pdf

Download media

More from this category

  • Finance Investment
  • 04/04/2025
  • 21:26
Bitget Limited

Bitget Secures El Salvador Digital Asset Service Provider (DASP) License After BSP Approval

VICTORIA, Seychelles, April 04, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Bitget, the leading cryptocurrency exchange and Web3 company, has obtained the Digital Asset Service Provider (DASP) license from El Salvador’s National Commission of Digital Assets (CNAD), expanding its regulatory framework within the country. This development comes after the earlier acquisition of the Bitcoin Services Provider (BSP) license in 2024. El Salvador is one of the pioneering jurisdictions passing comprehensive legislation supporting the integration of Bitcoin and digital assets into its financial ecosystem and acting as its official currency. It has started to emerge as a hub for global crypto businesses.With both the…

  • Political
  • 04/04/2025
  • 15:11
Liberals Against Nuclear

Nuclear support collapses in host communities – Coalition must rethink

Liberals Against Nuclear is calling on the Coalition leadership to urgently reconsider its nuclear energy policy as new polling reveals overwhelming opposition in communities designated to host nuclear reactors. "These polling results should sound alarm bells within our party. Nuclear energy is being rejected by the very communities we're proposing to build reactors in," said Andrew Gregson, spokesperson for Liberals Against Nuclear. Research conducted by 89 Degrees East shows support for nuclear at just 27% in Gladstone and 24% in the rest of Central Queensland – regions central to the Coalition's nuclear plan. Other proposed sites showed similarly poor results…

  • Business Company News, Finance Investment
  • 04/04/2025
  • 10:05
Jane Morgan Management

WT Financial Group Launches First “Hubco” – Uniting Titan, Darwin FS and Wealth Connect

WT Financial Group (ASX:WTL) has announced plans to roll up three well-established financial advisory firms—Titan Financial Planning, Darwin Financial & Retirement Services, and Wealth Connect Financial Services—into a newly formed national group called “Hubco.” This initiative marks the first major step in WTL’s 50/50 joint venture with Merchant Wealth Partners, through the new investment vehicle, WTL & MWP Investco. The innovative strategy is aimed at bringing scale and shared infrastructure to independent advice businesses, while retaining their entrepreneurial roots. Backed by Strategic Capital The venture will see Investco inject an initial $3.5 million into the newly formed Hubco, giving it…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.