Skip to content
International News, Political

Victim-blaming, manipulation, and denial: How terrorists use language to justify violence

Charles Darwin University 2 mins read
The study by Dr Awni Etaywe explores an under-researched area of tactics used in terrorist threat texts and their investigative value.

Victim-blaming, denial and reversal are among the tactics used by terrorists to justify their violent actions and influence audience perceptions of harm and agency, according to a new Charles Darwin University (CDU) study examining the language of some of the world’s most notorious individuals. 

The study by CDU Linguistics Lecturer and Forensic Linguistics expert Dr Awni Etaywe analysed rhetoric used in texts by Osama Bin Laden, former Boko Haram leader Abubaker Shekau, and Christchurch Mosque gunman Brenton Tarrant.

The analysis revealed the individuals used a variety of linguistic tactics to justify their respective violent actions such as ‘discrediting’ that is to tarnish a target subject to challenge their credibility and capabilities, ‘blaming and denying’ to shift responsibility and blame onto victims, and ‘deontic retaliation’ which involves a variety of tactics terrorists use to present an act of violence as a justified response or retaliation to a past event or offence.

The analysis also shows the individuals use the ‘boulomaic function’, chiefly via wording such as ‘want’, ‘wish’ and ‘hope’ to express the fantasy desire to cause harm without coercing specific actions. 

Dr Etaywe said while the individuals adopted a variety of the above, all presented themselves positively while portraying victims negatively. 

“This approach articulates beliefs advantageous to threateners while discrediting, delegitimising and blaming victims,” Dr Etaywe said. 

“Discrediting is notably prominent in the ‘manipulation’ by texts of Bin Laden and Shekau to influence victim’s behaviour through deterrence or compulsion. Bin Laden strategically employs discrediting in his threat texts to sway the American people’s trust in their political leadership, particularly the Bush administration’s propriety, tenacity and veracity, and to influence anti-war sentiment and stance towards war.

“Shekau’s act of discrediting serves to undermine governance and power image in Nigeria. Shekau enhances his own capacity while casting doubt on the victims’ capacity, manipulating their perception of his power and his opponents’ incapability.

“The boulomaic function is evident in Tarrant’s texts. The bursty repetition of the verb ‘want’ in the context of direct threats emphasises this strong inclination.” 

Dr Etaywe said by examining the texts, it allows experts to understand how threats can force behavioural compliance (through e.g. manipulation and retaliation) and cause damage to the subjects of the texts, and how threat texts can offer clues to author’s commitment to violence. 

“This offers insight to criminal interrogators on why some texts are polarising, radicalising and mind-unsettling,” he said. 

Dr Etaywe is a leading expert in forensic linguistics focusing on terrorism, cybercrime, and digital deviance. His previous research includes a study examining how terrorists use language to mobilise support and legitimise harm, and a study on how far-right conspiratorially terrorist discourse leverages social bonds to incite hatred and radical actions – that is the role of social affiliation in incitement. 

Dr Etaywe said this analysis helps society to understand how similar linguistic tactics are used by individuals many might not consider violent extremist, such as former President Donald Trump, to influence and manipulate public perception and behaviour in contemporary media discourse.

‘Discursive pragmatics of justification in terrorist threat texts: Victim-blaming, denying, discrediting, legitimating, manipulating, and retaliation’ was published in the journal Discourse & Society.


Contact details:

Raphaella Saroukos she/her
Research Communications Officer
Marketing, Media & Communications
Larrakia Country
T: +61 8 8946 6721
E: media@cdu.edu.au
W: cdu.edu.au

Media

More from this category

  • International News, Medical Health Aged Care
  • 13/06/2024
  • 10:12
Charles Darwin University

CDU EXPERT: It’s getting hot in here – we need to learn to live with it

13 JUNE, 2024 Who: Charles Darwin University heat stress expert Dr Sarah Carter. Dr Carter is a member of the Heat and Health Research Incubator group, and has been part of the team implementing the Australian Open heat stress scales. Topics: The impact of heatwaves on the human body, following recent heatwaves in Delhi and Athens. How to manage and adapt to heat stress. Internal and external factors contributing to heat stress. Contact details: Call +61 8 8946 6721 or email media@cdu.edu.au to arrange an interview. Quotes attributable to Dr Sarah Carter: "Heatwaves provide significant stress to our systems by…

  • Finance Investment, Political
  • 12/06/2024
  • 09:34
Super Members Council

Dodgy financial advisers who use click-bait and cold calls to drum up business should be put in the legal freezer

Anti-hawking laws should be tightened, and current consumer protections locked into law to stop dodgy financial advisers using click-bait social media posts, cold-calls and pressure sales tactics to move unsuspecting Australians into a dud super fund and charging them thousands in fees, the Super Members Council says. The Super Members Council is calling for the Australian Government to extend anti-hawking laws, so it bans a small subset of financial advisers from using cold-calling businesses to get clients. Parliament should also swiftly pass the financial advice legislation currently before it, which locks into law the current robust consumer protections that require…

  • Contains:
  • Animal Animal WelfareRights, International News
  • 12/06/2024
  • 09:28
Humane Society International Australia

Iceland will allow commercial whaling to resume in ‘devastatingly disappointing’ renewal of one-year permit

This is a rejection of once-in-a-generation opportunity to end slaughter at sea, says Humane Society International (11 June 2024)―Asnews breaksthat Iceland’s Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Minister Bjarkey Olsen Gunnarsdóttir will renew a one-year commercial whaling licence to whaling company Hvalur hf., despite clear evidence of immense animal suffering, global animal protection charity Humane Society International calls it a devastatingly disappointing decision. An independentreportpublished last year by the Icelandic Food and Veterinary Authority revealed some whales killed in Icelandic hunts had taken up to two hours to die, with 41% of whales suffering immensely before dying for an average of 11.5…

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.