Skip to content
Defence, Government Federal

Procurement of the $??,000,000,000 Hunter Class Frigates and the future of the Defence Major Projects Reports

Parliament of Australia 3 mins read

The former Government breached Finance law by failing to undertake any value for money assessments before awarding a (then) $35 billion Defence contract, current value still unknown.

The Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit has tabled its final report today for its Inquiry into the Defence Major Projects Report (MPR) 2020-21 and 2021-22 and Procurement of Hunter Class Frigates.

The Committee’s interim report for the inquiry in June 2023 dealt with cost, schedule, and capability performance assessments in both MPRs and other common themes including the impacts of COVID-19, Defence projects of interest and concern, and issues around risk management and capability forecasting. This final report has considered the future of the MPR itself and highlighted key issues and concerns with the ongoing Hunter Class Frigate program.

$??,000,000,000 Hunter Class Frigates Procurement

The Committee was deeply concerned that no value for money assessment was ever undertaken by Defence or the former Government on the Hunter Class Frigates’ tenders, despite which the National Security Committee of Cabinet decided to proceed with a (then) $35 billion procurement of a ship from BAE Systems that was not a mature design.

Perplexingly, clear failings in the procurement identified by ANAO were only belatedly accepted by Defence after the Committee initiated this inquiry and Defence conducted its own internal review.

Committee Chair Julian Hill MP stated that “Ministers are not supposed to be rubber stamps or daleks, and there are two possibilities as to how this happened: 1) either no one noticed that no value for money assessment was undertaken or 2) they did know but didn’t care and blithely decided to proceed with a (then) $35 billion procurement anyway.

“Ultimately as this was a Cabinet process via the National Security Committee of Cabinet no one will ever really know what happened; whether there was a conspiracy or predetermined decision that BAE win the prize, or whether it was simply shocking incompetence by this group of Ministers in the then government.”

Further issues raised in the audit that were of significant concern to the Committee included:

  • the absence of any explanation why 10% was mysteriously knocked off the price from all tenderers in the evaluation and advice to government – the Committee’s report reaches blunt conclusions on this point:
    • “While the Committee would love to think the Commonwealth could just buy everything for 10 per cent less than a tendered price, it’s a patently ridiculous proposition and vague claims there might be an “efficiency dividend” raise reasonable questions about the competence of officials involved. Indeed, it is not apparent to any member of the Committee whether there has ever been an Australian shipbuilding project for such a major new capability that has run under budget.”
  • the Hunter Class Frigate itself was assessed by Defence experts as a mature design when it had in fact never been built or even fully designed;
  • key documents regarding the decision-making process went and remain missing.

Mr Hill commented that “Defence must reassess how it determines maturity in future large-scale acquisitions, particularly as foreign governments will always be keen to sell expensive military hardware to Australia. A balance is needed between that approach and acquiring ‘off-the-shelf’ military capability.”

The Committee makes five recommendations in relation to the Hunter Class Frigate program. Four of these request updates from Defence on changes arising from its internal review, progress with the project, how it will assess design maturity in the future, and its new recordkeeping framework.

The Committee is also recommending that the Commonwealth Procurement Rules now explicitly require a value for money assessment in a tender evaluation plan as a default option which must then be cleared by the Department of Finance.

Future of the MPR

The Committee regards the MPR as an important accountability mechanism that should continue for the foreseeable future, albeit with potential adjustments. Mr Hill stated that “although other external accountability and assurance mechanisms for scrutinising Defence activities exist, the MPR provides a structured level of scrutiny across major capability projects that would not be provided through these other processes.”

Mr Hill further commented that “the discipline of the MPR has positive impacts on Defence’s internal management of major projects.”

The Committee noted the tension between national security considerations and need for ANAO to provide transparency to the Parliament and is recommending that a confidential submission and related briefings with Defence, where information cannot be published, now be provided by ANAO as a supplement to the MPR. 

The report can be downloaded from the inquiry website.

Media inquiries

Mr Julian Hill MP, Chair of the Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit
Electorate office: (03) 9791 7770

For background information

Committee Secretariat
02 6277 4615
jcpaa@aph.gov.au

For more information about this Committee, you can visit its website. On the site, you can make a submission to an inquiry, read other submissions, and get details for upcoming public hearings. You can also track the Committee and receive email updates by clicking on the blue ‘Track Committee’ button in the bottom right-hand corner of the page.

More from this category

  • Environment, Government Federal
  • 24/07/2024
  • 16:00
House of Representatives

Hitting the road: Committee to hold public hearings for EV inquiry

TheHouse of Representatives Standing Committee on Climate Change, Energy, Environment and Waterwill be holding public hearings in Sydney on Thursday and Friday for its inquiry into the transition to electric vehicles (EVs). Chair of the Committee,Mr Tony Zappia MP, said ‘The public hearings will be an opportunity to further explore the priorities necessary to support Australia’s transition to EVs.’ ‘The Committee is looking forward to hearing from a diverse range of stakeholders who can offer insight into a number of issues, including the manufacturing and charging of EVs, experiences using EV fleets, and opportunities for the safe and equitable uptake…

  • Government Federal, Local Government
  • 24/07/2024
  • 14:58
House of Representatives

Challenges and risks facing local government sustainability

Local government associations from Queensland, Tasmania and New South Wales will appear before the House of RepresentativesStanding Committee on Regional Development, Infrastructure and Transportas part of an ongoing inquiry into local government sustainability. Thevirtual public hearing on 25 July 2024continues the Committee’s in-depth examination of the financial sustainability challenges and risks facing local government. The Committee will also hear from the Australian Services Union, the Northern and Yorke Local Government Association, Torrens University Australia, Always Thinking Advisory, and the United Services Union and Local Government Engineers Association. Chair of the Committee,Mr Luke Gosling OAM, MP, said ‘the hearing will provide…

  • Government Federal, Taxation
  • 23/07/2024
  • 17:58
Australian Taxation Office

The ATO is here to help during tax time

The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) is committed to helping taxpayers get their tax returns right this tax time. For some, managing their tax affairs may seem tricky but theATO is here to help with support and guidance forthose struggling with their tax obligations. Tax Help and Tax Clinics If you’re earning under $60,000 you may be eligible for the Tax Help program where from July to October each year, ATO-accredited volunteers help people to lodge their tax returns online. You can speak to a Tax Help volunteer in person at Tax Help centres across Australia for help with your tax…

  • Contains:

Media Outreach made fast, easy, simple.

Feature your press release on Medianet's News Hub every time you distribute with Medianet. Pay per release or save with a subscription.