The Super Members Council welcomes the Federal Government’s plan to extend the performance test to more super products – and urges it to close the remaining gaps in coverage, as millions of Australians still miss out on this key consumer protection despite the planned expansion.
The performance test is a key safeguard for Australians’ retirement savings, helping to drive strong returns, low fees, and weed out underperforming products.
The proposed expansion of the test to externally directed accumulation super products is an important step towards broader and more consistent consumer protections.
But a critical gap still needs closing. Two people could invest in exactly the same super product, but one could be protected by the performance test and the other may not be, simply because they accessed the investment through a different pathway.
Super Members Council’s CEO Misha Schubert warns the remaining gaps leave millions of Australians “flying blind” on whether their super is performing – including many people invested through super ‘platforms’.
“We welcome the extension of the super performance test to more products. This expansion will give more Australians clearer visibility on whether their super is performing, but there remain gaps that still leave millions of consumers essentially flying blind, not knowing if their super is meeting the performance benchmarks or not.”
“The fact that 12,000 Australians have been exposed to products like the collapsed Shield and First Guardian schemes — which were listed on four super platforms and weren’t subject to the performance test — shows why closing the remaining test coverage gaps is both urgent and essential.”
The proposed new CPI-plus benchmark for emerging assets addresses some investment barriers for growth assets with strong long-term return prospects not adequately captured by existing market benchmarks.
The proposed 5% cap on emerging assets, applying the new arrangements only to future investments, and regularly reviewing benchmarks closely, are important guardrails.
The Council welcomes standing periodic performance test reviews and embedding benchmarks into an APRA determination as practical ways to ensure the test remains fit for purpose.
The announced changes do not tackle fee gaming that obscures underperformance on returns. It is important that administration fees are measured on the same ten-year period as investment performance to improve transparency, comparability and better protect consumers.
Due to the single year approach to reporting on fees, trustees on the cusp of failing the test can temporarily cut their administration fees to sidestep failure and retain members in borderline sub-standard products, without fixing their fundamental under-performance issues.
“Any careful adjustments to the test’s design must ultimately boost Australians’ savings by generating strong, long-term risk-adjusted returns while maintaining crucial consumer protections,” Ms Schubert said.
“The test should measure fees over the same long-term period as investment performance, so members get a clearer picture of net benefits and how their super is really performing."
ENDS
About us:
The opinions above are those of the author in their capacity as spokesperson for Super Members Council of Australia (SMC). SMC, the authors and all other persons involved in the preparation of this information are thereby not giving legal, financial or professional advice for individual persons or organisations.
Contact details:
Mike Dolan, 0474 909 471, [email protected]